Home » Public Forums » GMCnet » Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF
Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294270] |
Sat, 23 January 2016 20:38 |
Larry
Messages: 2875 Registered: January 2004 Location: Menomonie, WI
Karma: 10
|
Senior Member |
|
|
I had my 425 rebuilt last summer. Taking the trans apart was at times difficult because all of the internal seals in the trans had turn soft and mushy. He said it was a good thing that the rebuild occured now because it probably wouldn't have lasted more than another couple of hundred miles. When asked if I had used any transmission additives with the fluid, my answer was no, that the only thing that the trans has seen is...when first installed I used Amsoil ATF and later, when I changed trans fluid because I had trouble finding Amsoil, I had switched to Mobil 1. I don't know if any one else has experienced this but in my mind and the rebuilders mind, there is to a minor degree, evidence that the two brands may not be completely compatible. So, FWIW, I would not mix these two brands. JWIT
Other explainations are welcome.
Larry
78 Royale w/500 Caddy
Menomonie, WI.
[Updated on: Sat, 23 January 2016 20:40] Report message to a moderator
|
|
|
Re: [GMCnet] Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294276 is a reply to message #294270] |
Sat, 23 January 2016 22:51 |
|
USAussie
Messages: 15912 Registered: July 2007 Location: Sydney, Australia
Karma: 6
|
Senior Member |
|
|
Larry,
Guess you shoulda followed this guy's procedure! ;-)
Regards,
Rob
-----Original Message-----
From: Larry
Sent: Tuesday, March 18, 2008 12:13 AM
To: gmclist
Subject: Drain Transmission & Torque Converter - COMPLETELY!
Rob,
You can take it to a "Jiffy Lube" type place to have them change the fluid, and to my way of thinking that is the only way to
*completely* change all of the fluid, as long as you have the filter changed also. The only catch is, the last couple of times I
stopped at a "Jiffy Lube" type place, they were *not* offering synthetic fluids as a change option. So you may have to make a sort
of deal with the owner/manager to use synthetic fluid. That being said, you can get most of the oil out using the following
procedure. Keep in mind, there are several...perhaps many... that would not do this (including IIRC Manny). I've done it many
times with no ill results. Sooooooo.....
This is a very messy procedure...you're gonna spill fluid, so be prepared with Oil dry, rags and the like to clean-up afterwards.
1. Do this with the trans cold. Wait at least over night.
2. Raise the coach high enough to get a 5 gal pail under it with room to spare.
3. Disconnect both trans lines at the radiator, and be prepared to catch the fluid coming out of the cooler in the radiator.
4. Attach hose extensions to the lines and drop the lines into the 5 gal pail.
5. Using two people, start the motor for only couple of seconds. Do this to identify which line the fluid will come out of. Now
you know
which line you *must* keep in the bucket.
6. Again, using two people, (one to run the motor, the other to watch the fluid) start the motor.
7. Run the motor until the fluid line begins spurting air. Shut motor off immediately!! The fluid will get quite frothy.
8. Allow to stand without the motor running for 4-5 minutes. This will let excess fluid in the trans drain down into the pan.
9. Start the motor again for no more than 5 seconds. Shut off the motor, This will pump out that last little bit in the pan and
make
dropping the pan a lot less messy.
10. Let the oil lines drip into the pail while you drop the trans pan.
11. Drop the trans pan, and replace the filter using two (2) "O" rings at the filter.
12. Hook up the two trans lines to the oil cooler at the radiator.
13. Fill the trans with about 7 qts of trans fluid.
14. Start the motor and allow it to idle for about 30 seconds or so before checking fluid level.
15. Check fluid level and add accordingly.
16. Once full, drive until normal operating temp is reached, and recheck fluid level. Add fluid to bring to "Full".
I've used this procedure on every auto trans that I've owned for....well....forever. This is just the way I do it....your mileage
may vary.
Just my relatively informed, off the cuff, back yard mechanic, gut level, eyeball it up and guesstimate, way of doing
things....that's all...
Larry :)
78 Royale w/500 Caddy
Menomonie, WI
-----Original Message-----
From: Larry
I had my 425 rebuilt last summer. Taking the trans apart was at times difficult because all of the internal seals in the trans had
turn soft and mushy. He said it was a good thing that the rebuild occured now because it probably wouldn't have lasted more than
another couple of hundred miles. When asked if I had used any transmission additives with the fluid, my answer was no, that the only
thing that the trans has seen is...when first installed I used Amsoil ATF and later, when I changed trans fluid because I had
trouble finding Amsoil, I had switched to Mobil 1. I don't know if any one else has experienced this but in my mind and the
rebuilders mind, there is to a minor degree, evidence that the two brands may not be completely compatible. So, FWIW, I would not
mix these two brands. JWIT
Other explainations are welcome.
--
Larry
_______________________________________________
GMCnet mailing list
Unsubscribe or Change List Options:
http://list.gmcnet.org/mailman/listinfo/gmclist_list.gmcnet.org
Regards,
Rob M. (USAussie)
The Pedantic Mechanic
Sydney, Australia
'75 Avion - AUS - The Blue Streak TZE365V100428
'75 Avion - USA - Double Trouble TZE365V100426
|
|
|
Re: [GMCnet] Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294294 is a reply to message #294276] |
Sun, 24 January 2016 09:21 |
Larry
Messages: 2875 Registered: January 2004 Location: Menomonie, WI
Karma: 10
|
Senior Member |
|
|
LOL...ya got me Rob. I did follow that procedure, but apparently it didn't get all of the old fluid out. Can you think of any other reason why all of the seals should turn mushy like that? This rebuilder had seen this before but happened when the owner had used trans chemicals who's purpose was to help stop leaks.
USAussie wrote on Sat, 23 January 2016 22:51Larry,
Guess you should followed this guy's procedure!
Regards,
Rob
-----Original Message-----
From: Larry
Sent: Tuesday, March 18, 2008 12:13 AM
To: gmclist
Subject: Drain Transmission & Torque Converter - COMPLETELY!
Rob,
You can take it to a "Jiffy Lube" type place to have them change the fluid, and to my way of thinking that is the only way to
*completely* change all of the fluid, as long as you have the filter changed also. The only catch is, the last couple of times I
stopped at a "Jiffy Lube" type place, they were *not* offering synthetic fluids as a change option. So you may have to make a sort
of deal with the owner/manager to use synthetic fluid. That being said, you can get most of the oil out using the following
procedure. Keep in mind, there are several...perhaps many... that would not do this (including IIRC Manny). I've done it many
times with no ill results. Sooooooo.....
This is a very messy procedure...you're gonna spill fluid, so be prepared with Oil dry, rags and the like to clean-up afterwards.
1. Do this with the trans cold. Wait at least over night.
2. Raise the coach high enough to get a 5 gal pail under it with room to spare.
3. Disconnect both trans lines at the radiator, and be prepared to catch the fluid coming out of the cooler in the radiator.
4. Attach hose extensions to the lines and drop the lines into the 5 gal pail.
5. Using two people, start the motor for only couple of seconds. Do this to identify which line the fluid will come out of. Now
you know
which line you *must* keep in the bucket.
6. Again, using two people, (one to run the motor, the other to watch the fluid) start the motor.
7. Run the motor until the fluid line begins spurting air. Shut motor off immediately!! The fluid will get quite frothy.
8. Allow to stand without the motor running for 4-5 minutes. This will let excess fluid in the trans drain down into the pan.
9. Start the motor again for no more than 5 seconds. Shut off the motor, This will pump out that last little bit in the pan and
make
dropping the pan a lot less messy.
10. Let the oil lines drip into the pail while you drop the trans pan.
11. Drop the trans pan, and replace the filter using two (2) "O" rings at the filter.
12. Hook up the two trans lines to the oil cooler at the radiator.
13. Fill the trans with about 7 qts of trans fluid.
14. Start the motor and allow it to idle for about 30 seconds or so before checking fluid level.
15. Check fluid level and add accordingly.
16. Once full, drive until normal operating temp is reached, and recheck fluid level. Add fluid to bring to "Full".
I've used this procedure on every auto trans that I've owned for....well....forever. This is just the way I do it....your mileage
may vary.
Just my relatively informed, off the cuff, back yard mechanic, gut level, eyeball it up and guesstimate, way of doing
things....that's all...
Larry
78 Royale w/500 Caddy
Menomonie, WI
-----Original Message-----
From: Larry
I had my 425 rebuilt last summer. Taking the trans apart was at times difficult because all of the internal seals in the trans had
turn soft and mushy. He said it was a good thing that the rebuild occured now because it probably wouldn't have lasted more than
another couple of hundred miles. When asked if I had used any transmission additives with the fluid, my answer was no, that the only
thing that the trans has seen is...when first installed I used Amsoil ATF and later, when I changed trans fluid because I had
trouble finding Amsoil, I had switched to Mobil 1. I don't know if any one else has experienced this but in my mind and the
rebuilders mind, there is to a minor degree, evidence that the two brands may not be completely compatible. So, FWIW, I would not
mix these two brands. JWIT
Other explainations are welcome.
--
Larry
_______________________________________________
GMCnet mailing list
Unsubscribe or Change List Options:
http://list.gmcnet.org/mailman/listinfo/gmclist_list.gmcnet.org
Larry
78 Royale w/500 Caddy
Menomonie, WI.
|
|
|
Re: Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294297 is a reply to message #294270] |
Sun, 24 January 2016 10:14 |
midlf
Messages: 2212 Registered: July 2007 Location: SE Wisc. (Palmyra)
Karma: 1
|
Senior Member |
|
|
I always figure it is probably OK to mix oils from different mfr's. However I KNOW FOR SURE that using the same brand, weight, and rating oil will not cause a mix problem. Your choice. I presume if you are familiar with all the oil industry standards you would be able to determine the probability for problems.
This would be something to research on "Bob is the oil guy" or other places on the net.
Steve Southworth
1974 Glacier TZE064V100150 (for workin on)
1975 Transmode TZE365V100394 (parts & spares)
Palmyra WI
|
|
|
|
Re: [GMCnet] Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294306 is a reply to message #294294] |
Sun, 24 January 2016 13:14 |
|
USAussie
Messages: 15912 Registered: July 2007 Location: Sydney, Australia
Karma: 6
|
Senior Member |
|
|
Larry,
I reckon that since you did use this procedure I'm surprised that there was enough Amsoil trans fluid mixed with the Mobil 1 fluid
to cause the mushy seal problem?
However, that statement is a SWAG as I have NO idea how much of the Amsoil was left behind.
An interesting experiment would be to take a brand new transmission, fill it with fluid recording the amount used, then drain it
using your procedure recording the amount you get out. That would tell you how much could not be pumped out.
Regards,
Rob M.
The Pedantic Mechanic
-----Original Message-----
From: Larry
LOL...ya got me Rob. I did follow that procedure, but apparently it didn't get all of the old fluid out. Can you think of any other
reason why all of the seals should turn mushy like that? This rebuilder had seen this before but happened when the owner had used
trans chemicals who's purpose was to help stop leaks.
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Larry
>
> I had my 425 rebuilt last summer. Taking the trans apart was at times difficult because all of the internal seals in the trans had
> turn soft and mushy. He said it was a good thing that the rebuild occured now because it probably wouldn't have lasted more than
> another couple of hundred miles. When asked if I had used any transmission additives with the fluid, my answer was no, that the
only
> thing that the trans has seen is...when first installed I used Amsoil ATF and later, when I changed trans fluid because I had
> trouble finding Amsoil, I had switched to Mobil 1. I don't know if any one else has experienced this but in my mind and the
> rebuilders mind, there is to a minor degree, evidence that the two brands may not be completely compatible. So, FWIW, I would not
> mix these two brands. JWIT
>
> Other explainations are welcome.
> --
> Larry
_______________________________________________
GMCnet mailing list
Unsubscribe or Change List Options:
http://list.gmcnet.org/mailman/listinfo/gmclist_list.gmcnet.org
Regards,
Rob M. (USAussie)
The Pedantic Mechanic
Sydney, Australia
'75 Avion - AUS - The Blue Streak TZE365V100428
'75 Avion - USA - Double Trouble TZE365V100426
|
|
|
Re: [GMCnet] Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294311 is a reply to message #294306] |
Sun, 24 January 2016 14:42 |
Larry
Messages: 2875 Registered: January 2004 Location: Menomonie, WI
Karma: 10
|
Senior Member |
|
|
USAussie wrote on Sun, 24 January 2016 13:14Larry,
I reckon that since you did use this procedure I'm surprised that there was enough Amsoil trans fluid mixed with the Mobil 1 fluid
to cause the mushy seal problem?
However, that statement is a SWAG as I have NO idea how much of the Amsoil was left behind.
An interesting experiment would be to take a brand new transmission, fill it with fluid recording the amount used, then drain it
using your procedure recording the amount you get out. That would tell you how much could not be pumped out.
Regards,
Rob M.
Na....not gonna do that. To many other things to deal with right now. The Mushy seal thing really has me wondering what I did to create the problem. You'd think that the two brands would be compatable, but the little cause and effect I have would kinda indicate that they might not be. In any case I'm not gonna chance it. Gonna use ONLY the Amsoil product. JWIT
Larry
78 Royale w/500 Caddy
Menomonie, WI.
|
|
|
|
Re: [GMCnet] Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294337 is a reply to message #294294] |
Sun, 24 January 2016 18:50 |
Ken Henderson
Messages: 8726 Registered: March 2004 Location: Americus, GA
Karma: 9
|
Senior Member |
|
|
Larry,
Your suggested procedure includes "../fill the transmission with about 7
quarts of ATF...". If that really fills the transmission, you'll be
interested to read page 0-11 of X-7525. It says that a freshly overhauled
transmission holds 12 quarts. In other words, you still probably had about
a 7/12=58%/42% Mobil1/Amsoil mix. :-(
No need for any messy experiment.
Ken H.
On Sun, Jan 24, 2016 at 10:21 AM, Larry wrote:
> LOL...ya got me Rob. I did follow that procedure, but apparently it didn't
> get all of the old fluid out. Can you think of any other reason why all of
> the seals should turn mushy like that? This rebuilder had seen this before
> but happened when the owner had used trans chemicals who's purpose was to
> help stop leaks.
>
_______________________________________________
GMCnet mailing list
Unsubscribe or Change List Options:
http://list.gmcnet.org/mailman/listinfo/gmclist_list.gmcnet.org
Ken Henderson
Americus, GA
www.gmcwipersetc.com
Large Wiring Diagrams
76 X-Birchaven
76 X-Palm Beach
|
|
|
|
Re: [GMCnet] Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294344 is a reply to message #294339] |
Sun, 24 January 2016 22:06 |
jimk
Messages: 6734 Registered: July 2006 Location: Belmont, CA
Karma: 9
|
Senior Member |
|
|
Along these lines, several years ago, majority of trans. shops had a
equipment that would flush almost all the old fluid and fill with new or we
knew how to do it without that equipment.
We did several trans. flush that way till we started running into a
situation where that unit we flushed would end up with a transmission
problem later.
We started hearing from other transmission shops about the same problem.
The best reasoning was that the new fluid has enough additives that loosen
up the old gunk that the gunk was getting stuck in the critical places and
creating problems.
We now change out what is in the pan only .
On Sun, Jan 24, 2016 at 5:07 PM, Larry wrote:
> Ken Henderson wrote on Sun, 24 January 2016 18:50
>> Larry,
>>
>> Your suggested procedure includes "../fill the transmission with about 7
>> quarts of ATF...". If that really fills the transmission, you'll be
>> interested to read page 0-11 of X-7525. It says that a freshly
> overhauled
>> transmission holds 12 quarts. In other words, you still probably had
> about
>> a 7/12=58%/42% Mobil1/Amsoil mix. :(
>>
>> No need for any messy experiment.
>>
>>
>> Ken H.
>
> Well now.......there ya go! Maybe now, closer to "don't mix the two"?
> --
> Larry
> 78 Royale w/500 Caddy
> Menomonie, WI.
>
> _______________________________________________
> GMCnet mailing list
> Unsubscribe or Change List Options:
> http://list.gmcnet.org/mailman/listinfo/gmclist_list.gmcnet.org
>
--
Jim Kanomata
Applied/GMC, Fremont,CA
jimk@appliedairfilters.com
http://www.appliedgmc.com
1-800-752-7502
_______________________________________________
GMCnet mailing list
Unsubscribe or Change List Options:
http://list.gmcnet.org/mailman/listinfo/gmclist_list.gmcnet.org
Jim Kanomata
Applied/GMC
jimk@appliedairfilters.com
www.appliedgmc.com
1-800-752-7502
|
|
|
Re: [GMCnet] Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294352 is a reply to message #294344] |
Mon, 25 January 2016 01:05 |
Ken Burton
Messages: 10030 Registered: January 2004 Location: Hebron, Indiana
Karma: 10
|
Senior Member |
|
|
Last year I flushed my 220,000 mile Blazer brakes. By the time I got done I ended up replacing 3 calipers, rebuilding the 4th one and rebuilding the master cylinder.
The same thing would also probably happen if I decided to flush the trans. That is the kind thing that shops face when they flush an unknown transmission.
Ken Burton - N9KB
76 Palm Beach
Hebron, Indiana
|
|
|
|
Re: Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294356 is a reply to message #294270] |
Mon, 25 January 2016 08:23 |
lqqkatjon
Messages: 2324 Registered: October 2010 Location: St. Cloud, MN
Karma: 5
|
Senior Member |
|
|
It is just my opinion, that I agree with JimK. I have seen lots of transmission on other cars go bad after a tranny "flush".
I also seen a dodge Dorango go through an oil can henry's front door into a intersection full of cars. with the tranny machine attached and no one in the driver seat. I do not know the magic answer to transmissions, as well as Engines. Some people can beat and not take care of one and it will last forever, and the next guy will follow all the proper steps, and have problems after problem, and every situation in between.
in today's day and age, you could of had bad quality or batch of seals installed? And maybe had nothing to do with any type of fluid you used, or mixed? You never know what you end up with when you buy stuff these days.
Jon Roche
75 palm beach
EBL EFI, manny headers, Micro Level, rebuilt most of coach now.
St. Cloud, MN
http://lqqkatjon.blogspot.com/
|
|
|
Re: Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294359 is a reply to message #294270] |
Mon, 25 January 2016 08:33 |
jhbridges
Messages: 8412 Registered: May 2011 Location: Braselton ga
Karma: -74
|
Senior Member |
|
|
Nobody in the driver's seat? Stupid is one of the few things duct tape won't fix.
--johnny
Foolish Carriage, 76 26' Eleganza(?) with beaucoup mods and add - ons.
Braselton, Ga.
I forgive them all, save those who hurt the dogs. They must answer to me in hell
|
|
|
Re: Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294360 is a reply to message #294359] |
Mon, 25 January 2016 08:52 |
lqqkatjon
Messages: 2324 Registered: October 2010 Location: St. Cloud, MN
Karma: 5
|
Senior Member |
|
|
They were flushing the tranny. Dorangos used to be famous for shifter not being locked into park, and can fall out of park and roll away. (they did finally do a recall) I only imagined with tranny machine pumping fluid, if it dropped into gear, it would drive away until it rips the tranny machines cord out of the wall. so with tranny machine flushing, engine running. She dropped into gear and through the door it went. Poor lady stopped because the light was Red got t-boned. tranny flushing machine was stuck under the dorango, hanging on.
Jon Roche
75 palm beach
EBL EFI, manny headers, Micro Level, rebuilt most of coach now.
St. Cloud, MN
http://lqqkatjon.blogspot.com/
|
|
|
Re: [GMCnet] Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294364 is a reply to message #294344] |
Mon, 25 January 2016 09:22 |
Carl S.
Messages: 4186 Registered: January 2009 Location: Tucson, AZ.
Karma: 13
|
Senior Member |
|
|
jimk wrote on Sun, 24 January 2016 21:06Along these lines, several years ago, majority of trans. shops had a
equipment that would flush almost all the old fluid and fill with new or we
knew how to do it without that equipment.
We did several trans. flush that way till we started running into a
situation where that unit we flushed would end up with a transmission
problem later.
We started hearing from other transmission shops about the same problem.
The best reasoning was that the new fluid has enough additives that loosen
up the old gunk that the gunk was getting stuck in the critical places and
creating problems.
We now change out what is in the pan only .
Jim Kanomata
Applied/GMC, Fremont,CA
jimk@appliedairfilters.com
http://www.appliedgmc.com
1-800-752-7502
_______________________________________________
GMCnet mailing list
Unsubscribe or Change List Options:
http://list.gmcnet.org/mailman/listinfo/gmclist_list.gmcnet.org
Another issue I have heard about with the transmission flush machines is that they subject the transmission to higher pressures, in places, than they normally run, and this can cause problems later on down the road.
Carl Stouffer
'75 ex Palm Beach
Tucson, AZ.
Chuck Aulgur Reaction Arm Disc Brakes, Quadrabags, 3.70 LSD final drive, Lenzi knuckles/hubs, Dodge Truck 16" X 8" front wheels, Rear American Eagles, Solar battery charging. GMCSJ and GMCMI member
|
|
|
Re: Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294388 is a reply to message #294270] |
Mon, 25 January 2016 13:12 |
JohnL455
Messages: 4447 Registered: October 2006 Location: Woodstock, IL
Karma: 12
|
Senior Member |
|
|
And like junkies sharing needles, you can get who knows what from the guy's car before you. Small debris or rubber bits can hose a valve body. I'll stick with GM Dexron like the trans was made for and change what is in the pan when it is not clear red on the stick. Easy.
John Lebetski
Woodstock, IL
77 Eleganza II
|
|
|
Re: [GMCnet] Mixing Mobil 1 and Amsoil ATF [message #294395 is a reply to message #294356] |
Mon, 25 January 2016 14:26 |
|
USAussie
Messages: 15912 Registered: July 2007 Location: Sydney, Australia
Karma: 6
|
Senior Member |
|
|
G'day,
I direct your attention to MM X-7525 / Section 0 / General Information / Pg 0-6 / Engine, Chassis, and Body Maintenance Schedule /
Lube and General Maintenance:
"Every 12 months or 12,000 miles - Automatic Transmission and Final Drive Lubricant - Change"
I reckon if this was followed changing the transmission fluid would not cause any problems as contaminants would not build up to
levels that could cause problems when flushed.
In my opinion the problem occurs when you buy a coach that has an unknown service history and the trans fluid hasn't been flushed
for years and YEARS!
Regards,
Rob M.
The Pedantic Mechanic
_______________________________________________
GMCnet mailing list
Unsubscribe or Change List Options:
http://list.gmcnet.org/mailman/listinfo/gmclist_list.gmcnet.org
Regards,
Rob M. (USAussie)
The Pedantic Mechanic
Sydney, Australia
'75 Avion - AUS - The Blue Streak TZE365V100428
'75 Avion - USA - Double Trouble TZE365V100426
|
|
|
Goto Forum:
Current Time: Sun Nov 17 10:48:43 CST 2024
Total time taken to generate the page: 0.01449 seconds
|